18th July 2014
Swedish “school voucher” system is guaranteed to fail since it is badly designed
A commentator pointed out a recent Slate article showing that the Swedish voucher system is a failure. I had one quick look and dismissed the Swedish model outright. It simply is NOT well designed. If you don't implement fundamental principles into it, it just won't work.
This view is further confirmed by a quick extract from a 2011 article, below:
"a system where funding follows the student regardless of their parents’ income. If a school chooses to be part of the voucher system, it has to be all-inclusive, provide national standards and have its performance monitored. And it has no right to charge its students fees beyond the voucher." [Source]
Results are poor – as expected.
A proper design would include key elements outlined in BFN.
The Swedish system is a sham. Don't point to this sham and tell me that the voucher system doesn't work!
First design the system properly and then let's talk.
ADDENDUM
Haven't reviewed this document but will do so: School vouchers in Sweden by Jan Sjunnesson
Did vouchers cause the decline in Swedish schools? by Tyler Cowen
This article in The Economist discusses the Swedish experiment: Education reform: A good choice?