29th October 2012
My position on Arvind Kejriwal, to clear the air for everyone
Every now and then, people scold me for not praising Arvind Kejriwal enough, or for trying to challenge some of his ideas and actions.
So let me cut and paste from a few recent emails/ Facebook posts.
But before I do that, let me note that till today, I've not come across any financial malfeasance by Arvind Kejriwal. He has made some errors (e.g. mixing foreign funding with political action, which I've critiqued elsewhere) but he is clearly a person of integrity.
That means he is a good man. So I have no reasons to NOT interact with Arvind. I am happy to talk to good people of all "brands" of ideas.
But just like in Baba Ramdev's case, I'd be failing in my duty towards India and Indians if I did not point out where Arvind is wrong.
I expect to be told when I'm wrong. There is no greater thing of value than finding an honest opponent. All learning advances through honest difference of opinion.
Similarly, I expect to be able to oppose GOOD people where I think they are wrong. When such good people decide to promote the right ideas, then we get the best outcome for society.
So now, this is an extract from my email to Sreelatha Menon, part of which was published in Business Standard.
I've personally met Arvind Kejriwal and tried to show him this more systematic way to reform, but he has not been responsive. I've not given up, and continue to try to reach out to him. However, I'm concerned that while we need more self-governance, we don't need government interference in our lives. Many of his ideas, such as fixing prices for essential commodities, are deeply socialist, and will take India further down the path of ruin. We need serious policy thinkers to come forward, not economics illiterates. Chanakya should be made mandatory reading for anyone interested in public life.
I fully support the idea that Arvind has joined politics. I think that is the right way to proceed. But no, I'd not be (nor will FTI members be) part of IAC's political effort unless we see strong policy alignment. Arvind is currently influenced by the Bhushans, who are hardcore socialists. Let Arvind become curious about good policy, then I'm happy to spend time to talk to him.
Note, clearly that I left the IAS and decided to devote my energy to the reform of India's governance not in because I care (or not care) for Arvind, but because I am driven by a single goal: the Total Transformation of India. In that process, I believe that the right way must be followed, and the right system established. Individuals are important, but systems must over-ride them. To that extent, Arvind is IRRELEVANT. Only his ideas are relevant. But unfortunately, his ideas are wrong.
So here's an extract from FB:
AB Join Forces with IAC… IAC is trying to unite all political parties with similar philosophies and principles.. Arvind only has a political vision of complete decentralisation. He does not have a economic vision. Join forces with IAC.. It is bound to be a win-win situation..
Sanjeev Sabhlok A, I've tried to contact Arvind. He is not interested in good policy. Pl. see my comments in Business Standard today: http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/sreelatha-menonkejriwal-club/490888/. FTI is focused on good policy. We have a different approach
AB Alright.. u may have different views. And he is really head strong. [Sanjeev: So am I, if you haven't noticed!] But remember, under the constitution all policy decisions will be taken by vote. As a political party u will have to convince hundreds of voters to vote for u. U will have to do similar stuff if u are a part of IAC.. He has a lot of influence in IAC coz people across the board respect him a lot. U have to win votes of the educated middle and upper middle class which is the primary workforce of IAC..
These people are not his blind followers. [Sanjeev: I've not seen the non-blind ones yet. Happy to meet them.] U have to convince them with logic and they will vote for u(provided u don't use words like 'most stupid man on corruption'). [Sanjeev: He is the most foolish man on the topic of corruption. How can I hide that fact?] Ultimately FTI as a political party will have to do the same but on a much much larger scale… U will take a long long time to create a big platform like IAC. even IAC is not big enough.. think about it… Ultimately the decision is yours. [Sanjeev: If all I wanted was power, I'd have joined Congress or BJP 25 years ago. No shortcuts please. Only the right path.]
The vision document has been misquoted a number of times by a number of media houses.. [Sanjeev: Maybe, but I've seen the original version in Hindi.] Anyways, we have found a number of short comings in it, and it is being revised.. [Sanjeev. That's good. I look forward to a freedom based policy program.] Be a part of IAC and try and sell your ideas.. This is the best audience u can get.. Forget about Arvind.. Think about the vast youth base IAC has… IT, CAs, Medical professionals,Engineers etc etc… Where else are u going to get educated people in 20s and 30s in such large numbers.. convice them with logic.. If u get personal with a man whom they see working 20 hours day, u will get no where.. Use logice..
Shailesh Saraf i do think that many people want to contribute to Arvind only on the condition that he FIRST becomes/thinks like them and/or agree to their conditions…this is non-starter since Arvind has achieved phenomenal success [Sanjeev: I agree, re: RTI. I commend his work in that field.] and proven his integrity, intentions, hard work, etc. and is extremely busy. [Sanjeev: Being busy is no excuse to be a socialist, I'm very sorry.] One should prove his commitment by contributing to his cause BEFORE expecting Arvind to pay significant attention. [Sanjeev: I don't want his attention. I am just speaking my mind. He can take it or leave it. ]
AB true Shailesh.. I am sure he meets hundreds of 'advisers' every day, who do nothing really. I, as an average volunteer have met a lot of such people too. Once a farmer leader had come to him from haryana and wanted Arvind to take up their issues and do a rally in their area. He said,''I am not going to do it. U organise a big rally urself, educate the farmers, bring them from the entire state together for a rally and I will definitely attend it". He has become a brand. This is tough, but this method proves the sincerity of the person. This is how leaders emerge.
SC One cannot please everybody all the Time…IAC is fighting its Own Battle FTI will also do it in due course of time, I am sure. FTI also would build up a Huge mass Base just as big as IAC. Tilll then, Arvind has Started a War with the Most powerful & Corrupt Politicians of India…Lets give him is due…Lets Admire his Guts and Strength. And if do not support him lets not criticize him and pull him down.
Sanjeev Sabhlok Dear friends, I simply don't care for Arvind Kejriwal or Shejriwal. It is PURELY about India's future. And if Arvind is unwilling to learn basic economics, he is simply irrelevant. I'm not trying to change Arvind. He better learn basic economics if he wants to bring change to India. His ignorance is rampant and problematic. I will speak the truth for in my mind it is not Arvind that matters but India. And India is 1 billion times bigger. So let FTI continue its job of plain speaking and offering alternatives that WILL work.
Let Arvind and his group of confused people carry on with their confusion. Sometimes confusions go on for 65 years, like the Nehruvian socialist confusion. Arvind is simply following that confusion. Let's not worry about Arvind too much. Just that the journalist specifically asked me about Arvind.
I'm not writing this blog, or my books, or working to bring outstanding leaders together on FTI for the sake of IAC or Arvind or Ramdev. This effort is NOT about any one of us. It is about EVERY Indian, and about India's future (and of the world). So let's focus on the key questions, not about Arvind or Ramdev.
I have tried for months to reach out to Arvind. He is (from what I can gather) avoiding any discussion with me or with FTI. That's a problem, for FTI is promoting a systematic (as opposed to ad hoc) approach based on liberty. And its leaders are impeccably honest. So why is he not interested in engaging with these good leaders and finding out more about liberty?
Indeed, to me the biggest problem is: why has he not joined Lok Satta? I've said that he should do so: repeatedly. I can't see why he is disrespecting perhaps the greatest leader in Indian politics today: JP.
I have many differences with JP, but I see him FAR ABOVE Arvind in calibre, in understanding of India's problems, in experience, and in his understanding about liberty.
So what should I conclude with all this?
>> That Arvind is determined to impose his SOCIALIST ideas on India.
His manifesto (here's the Hindi PDF) is blatantly socialist.
Even Baba Ramdev has shown willingness to at least talk to me, and listen to my suggestions regarding Chanakya's Arthashastra. But Arvind seems to have made up his mind to take India FURTHER down the path of socialism.
I've met him. I've sent him 15 emails. He personally promised to read my book and write to me. No response. A number of people close to him have mentioned BFN to him. But no response.
I PROMISE to oppose ANY socialist in the world, particularly in India. Tooth and nail. Let that be clear to all his "followers".
I have not quit my job (to escape socialists) and put in tens of thousands of hours of work only to "kowtow" to yet another socialist. No one can make me respect any socialist. The question of my supporting socialist IAC does not arise.
I once again invite Arvind to stop his mad rush into socialism.
If he finds it odd to read my book, let him start with Arthashastra.