One-stop shop to make India 20 times richer

How can Indians possibly believe that MMS is upright?

I have long argued that anyone who joins the corrupt gang commonly known as Congress Party (or, indeed, any other major political outfit in India), is to be deemed to be corrupt.

The idea that someone can be upright but actively support a gang of crooks is untenable. It boggles belief that, for instance, that MMS did not know at the time of joining Congress  that the entire Congress operation runs on black money, money stolen from government contracts, and from direct bribes for favours to be performed. This fact is common knowledge within the entire government apparatus.

As an ordinary bureaucrat privy to a number of conversations (and incidents which pointed straight to the top!) with politicians and their advisers, and others who had first hand knowledge of them, even I KNEW this to be the case. The circumstantial evidence was overwhelming. The logic why this is happening is also straight forward (electoral expenses being the key reason).

Had I, in 2000, decided to join a mainstream political party (and thus forgo all my self-respect) I would have almost certainly become a senior Cabinet minister by now. I might even have maintained an image as an upright man. But that would have been a FALSE image. I would have cheated no one but myself. But MMS, hungry for power and perks, did not have any reservations about joining this gang.

Too long I have heard that MMS is upright but that people around him are not.

Absurd!!!

How can that be! 

How can anyone claim to be upright as a Prime Minister and now know precisely what is going around him. By joining such Congress, by not speaking out against this gang of thugs (who have looted the country in a bigger way than anyone else in India's history), MMS is FULLY complicit in the crimes being conducted on a daily basis by the Congress party.

MMS was never particularly competent. He NEVER had a clear theory of the state nor of the significance of human freedom. A minor thinker, he had the fortune of taking certain 'decisions' that were forced upon India by the IMF. Not merely a minor thinker, he is spineless, and I would argue deeply involved since he has clearly been running after position and perk, not after India's interests, and not after truth.

Indians are very gullible. All kinds of petty magicians deceive them into thinking that they are 'God'. In this case MMS has made a BIG fool out of Indians, by pretending to be upright.

The same Indians keep 'hoping' that Rahul Gandhi will be honest. 

Forget it! Stop dreaming.

Please start THINKING. Stop believing.

The cause is bad policy that makes corruption inevitable. The bad policies must be eradicated. The Freedom Team of India is assembling leaders who will offer to do this for India. Then, and only then, will India know what honesty means. Read FTI's Code of Conduct.

Addendum

Manmohan Singh is a Seriously Despicably Dishonest Spineless Toady Who Will Pay for his Crimes Against India (by Atanu Dey)

View more posts from this author
24 thoughts on “How can Indians possibly believe that MMS is upright?
  1. Bhagwad Jal Park

    This is like saying that any person working for Enron or Satyam was a thief. Everyone knows that large companies indulge in bribery and corruption. That doesn’t mean everyone who works in those companies is a horrible person.
     
    Sometimes people join organizations just because they have to do something, earn money, or don’t think too much. So I’m not willing to accept that every single person in the Congress is corrupt. That’s a very simplistic way of looking at things.

     
  2. Bhagwad Jal Park

    This is like saying that any person working for Enron or Satyam was a thief. Everyone knows that large companies indulge in bribery and corruption. That doesn’t mean everyone who works in those companies is a horrible person.
     
    Sometimes people join organizations just because they have to do something, earn money, or don’t think too much. So I’m not willing to accept that every single person in the Congress is corrupt. That’s a very simplistic way of looking at things.

     
  3. Sanjeev Sabhlok

    Sorry Bhagwad

    You are NOT getting my point. Entering a private sector company on a paid job is NOT the same as entering a political party as a leader. As an employee of Satyam you are an AGENT. As a leader of a political party you are a PRINCIPAL.

    It is naive and foolish – and typical of the way educated Indians think – to mix up the two roles. The ‘educated’ Indians think that joining Congress is a JOB under the Gandhi dynasty, so we can be honest while our boss is corrupt. That doesn’t work my friend!

    Regards
    Sanjeev

     
  4. Sanjeev Sabhlok

    Sorry Bhagwad

    You are NOT getting my point. Entering a private sector company on a paid job is NOT the same as entering a political party as a leader. As an employee of Satyam you are an AGENT. As a leader of a political party you are a PRINCIPAL.

    It is naive and foolish – and typical of the way educated Indians think – to mix up the two roles. The ‘educated’ Indians think that joining Congress is a JOB under the Gandhi dynasty, so we can be honest while our boss is corrupt. That doesn’t work my friend!

    Regards
    Sanjeev

     
  5. Bhagwad Jal Park

    In your first sentence in the post, you’ve said that anyone who joins the Congress in guilty – not just those who take up positions as leaders. I can happily be a secretary, draw a salary quietly and not care about what my superiors in the organization are doing.

     
  6. Bhagwad Jal Park

    In your first sentence in the post, you’ve said that anyone who joins the Congress in guilty – not just those who take up positions as leaders. I can happily be a secretary, draw a salary quietly and not care about what my superiors in the organization are doing.

     
  7. Bhagwad Jal Park

    The Maoists kidnapped an honest district collector (TOI link) and when asked why they did it, replied: “He is part of an imperialist order.”
    This is what happens when you over generalize, compartmentalize, and label everyone in a group. It shares similar traits with racism. Even the Supreme court has ruled recently that mere membership of even a banned organization means nothing unless the person has actually done something illegal themselves.
    It may be convenient to label everyone in a group for easy targeting, but once again it’s simplistic lazy thinking and certainly not scientific.

     
  8. Bhagwad Jal Park

    The Maoists kidnapped an honest district collector (TOI link) and when asked why they did it, replied: “He is part of an imperialist order.”
    This is what happens when you over generalize, compartmentalize, and label everyone in a group. It shares similar traits with racism. Even the Supreme court has ruled recently that mere membership of even a banned organization means nothing unless the person has actually done something illegal themselves.
    It may be convenient to label everyone in a group for easy targeting, but once again it’s simplistic lazy thinking and certainly not scientific.

     
  9. Sanjeev Sabhlok

    Dear Bhagwad

    You simply don’t get it! That’s typical Indian “educated” classes. The Congress organisation is rotten to the CORE. Everyone who has had even the slightest knowledge of India knows that. Everyone uses black money ALL the time. Even MMS must have made use of it on 10000s of occasions. He simply can’t avoid it. There are NO public accounts, no disclosure, no honesty from top to bottom.

    You are not telling me that when someone voluntarily and knowingly JOINS a corrupt organisation he is innocent! That he can still call himself upright?

    The DC’s example is still back to the same issue: A DC is an AGENT, not PRINCIPAL. As a PRINCIPAL (i.e. equal owner of an organisation), you are RESPONSIBLE for the entire organisation. As an agent, you are only responsible for yourself.

    Can’t distinguish two fundamental concepts?

    Regards
    Sanjeev

     
  10. Sanjeev Sabhlok

    Dear Bhagwad

    You simply don’t get it! That’s typical Indian “educated” classes. The Congress organisation is rotten to the CORE. Everyone who has had even the slightest knowledge of India knows that. Everyone uses black money ALL the time. Even MMS must have made use of it on 10000s of occasions. He simply can’t avoid it. There are NO public accounts, no disclosure, no honesty from top to bottom.

    You are not telling me that when someone voluntarily and knowingly JOINS a corrupt organisation he is innocent! That he can still call himself upright?

    The DC’s example is still back to the same issue: A DC is an AGENT, not PRINCIPAL. As a PRINCIPAL (i.e. equal owner of an organisation), you are RESPONSIBLE for the entire organisation. As an agent, you are only responsible for yourself.

    Can’t distinguish two fundamental concepts?

    Regards
    Sanjeev

     
  11. Bhagwad Jal Park

    Perhaps we need to look at things from a practical point of view. A person does what they can to the best of their ability. Given MMS’s situation he might simply be doing the best that he can. What do you expect him to do that will lead to a better outcome for everyone?
    Even during WWII when the Nazis were killing jews, there were military generals who were not just agents and were decent people who didn’t approve of what was going on. What could they do? Could they have stopped it? No. They did their duty.
    A man does what he can even in the middle of filth. And I’m glad that such people exist.

     
  12. Bhagwad Jal Park

    Perhaps we need to look at things from a practical point of view. A person does what they can to the best of their ability. Given MMS’s situation he might simply be doing the best that he can. What do you expect him to do that will lead to a better outcome for everyone?
    Even during WWII when the Nazis were killing jews, there were military generals who were not just agents and were decent people who didn’t approve of what was going on. What could they do? Could they have stopped it? No. They did their duty.
    A man does what he can even in the middle of filth. And I’m glad that such people exist.

     
  13. Sanjeev Sabhlok

    Dear Bhagwad

    People like MMS act as a front and deceive the public. You are one of them – 100% fooled!

    Please don’t compare with those who OPPOSED Hitler’s work even as they worked under him. MMS has NEVER ONCE opposed corruption, never ONCE taken any action to stop corruption or the use of black money in Congress. HE IS HANDS IN GLOVE.

    I leave off here since when even people like you are so COMPLETELY FOOLED then what can we talk of the common voter.

    India gets the government it DESERVES. Period.

    Let’s close off this now. I can’t keep repeating the same thing 1000000 times.

    Regards

    Sanjeev

     
  14. Sanjeev Sabhlok

    Dear Bhagwad

    People like MMS act as a front and deceive the public. You are one of them – 100% fooled!

    Please don’t compare with those who OPPOSED Hitler’s work even as they worked under him. MMS has NEVER ONCE opposed corruption, never ONCE taken any action to stop corruption or the use of black money in Congress. HE IS HANDS IN GLOVE.

    I leave off here since when even people like you are so COMPLETELY FOOLED then what can we talk of the common voter.

    India gets the government it DESERVES. Period.

    Let’s close off this now. I can’t keep repeating the same thing 1000000 times.

    Regards

    Sanjeev

     
  15. Abhi

    Bhagwad
    The funds for CWG to the tune of 70,000 crores was cleared by MMS signature. He knows that this is a ridiculous amount for a sporting event or related development. Here he cannot say he didnt know like the 2G scam.
    He is involved in corruption.
     

     
  16. Abhi

    Bhagwad
    The funds for CWG to the tune of 70,000 crores was cleared by MMS signature. He knows that this is a ridiculous amount for a sporting event or related development. Here he cannot say he didnt know like the 2G scam.
    He is involved in corruption.
     

     
  17. Abhi

    India has gone to dogs because our Armed forces do not have spine to free the country from yolk of these corrupt people who are stealing the country. Army Generals are subservient to the sycophants. Army generals themselves have become spineless when they don’t protest the shielding of Afzal Guru who killed many army men.
    But I still say army , because no amount of campaign, activism or struggle by common man can get rid them because Congress/politicians are well entrenched with lots of money. They will easily break any opposition.
    Has common people of India even revolted against tyranny in 1000 years of history?
    One has to make links with Army to make any sure any political activity has some credence and some weight. Else this activism is futile.

     
  18. Abhi

    India has gone to dogs because our Armed forces do not have spine to free the country from yolk of these corrupt people who are stealing the country. Army Generals are subservient to the sycophants. Army generals themselves have become spineless when they don’t protest the shielding of Afzal Guru who killed many army men.
    But I still say army , because no amount of campaign, activism or struggle by common man can get rid them because Congress/politicians are well entrenched with lots of money. They will easily break any opposition.
    Has common people of India even revolted against tyranny in 1000 years of history?
    One has to make links with Army to make any sure any political activity has some credence and some weight. Else this activism is futile.

     
  19. chetan

     

    Adv. Chetan T. Jadhav wrote:

    The Art of Spending (Black Money)
    As nearly every local municipal leaders, nearly every MLAs, MPs, Ministers and nearly all Government Officials of State and Central Government along with large industrialists have perfected the art of avoiding the money to land into treasury or government income account by all sorts of revenue and taxes, they all have perfected the art of converting government earnings into black money. They also have perfected the art of snatching income of farmers, labourers, workmen, employees and servants and converting the same into black money.
    Since most of the senior political leaders, MPs, MLAs and all major & famous industrialists are holding most of the black money outside india, it is but natural that ruling government is avoiding to declare the details and avoiding to bring the black money inside india.
    This article is for that situation when ultimately the government of India decides to bring the black money inside india.
    Then the question will be how to avoid these perfect snatchers from again snatching the money kept in outside india bank accounts by way of secret accounts i.e. BLACK MONEY.
    The government of india even having knowledge of the money, where it is kept and the procedure to bring the same into india is finding very very difficult to keep the corrupts hands off from this black money.
    Direct and sudden danger:- (danger inside government) The central and/or state governments or ministers or officials may miuse the money 1) by using the same for importing low quality goods for higher prices and accept bribe in terms of gold. 2) for foreign tours, foreign real estate investment etc.., 3) for defense, computer, chemical or any type of technology purchase which is basically not required and sideline huge amount for their personal gains. 4) For funding of earth saving scheme, environment protection schemes, scientific projects, space research, atomic research, social schemes, funding poor nations for their social schemes, funding poor nations for their economic and academic growth, funding private projects like save a river, forest, sea from pollution or erosion. And while doing so earn handsome personal gain.
    (danger from outside -the actual market) All those persons who are actually holding the account and their black money which is otherwise ancestral property, may misuse the money for:-
    1) Importing low quality products, not necessary products, luxury products, fancy techknology, cosmetics and all sorts of luxury products and services 2) Use the money for foreign tours and tourism, use the money for foreign real estate investment, use the money for
    Any type of use of money in India by either government or by the actual money holder will ruin the entire indian economy. It will surely collapse the existing hard working indian structure and dooms day like situation may emerge.
    One thing is for sure this money cannot be utilised until the indian government is purified, desciplined and corruption free and the money is cautiously used for every ordinary human be it poor or rich or backward or civilzed.
    Since as on today entire government machinery is very much corrupt this is not the proper time to bring the entire funds inside india. Keep it outside till we develop into desciplined civilized society without corruption.
    What will be method to utilize the money outside India?
    Priority No. 1 Repay all debt
    1) Repay all the international loans and money borrowed from any nation or nations or IMF or world bank or UN repay all outside india debt.
    2) Refund all the money which is taken as loan by every state from the central government.
    3) Refund all the money to the investors who had investmented in government scheme like national savings scheme.
    4) Refund every sort of debt which is taken by the state and central government from either industry society or public at large.
    5) Priority no.2 Repay every pending bills of all works done
    Priority no.2 sustatinable economic development investment.
    1) Ask all those persons holding black money outisde india, not bring the money inside india but invest it abroad only. Invest in sustainable economic development projects.
    Priority no.3 Form a bank (Establish a bank outside india)
    Using the huge amount outside india, india can establish a bank which will commercially fund industrial projects and scheme. Only commercial, financial, industrial profit oriented lending and no sympathy, social lending. This bank will not operate as any aid or social service agency but it will purely act as proft oriented bank.
    What could be the option starting bringing the funds in india.
    One must understand the ecological balance consept of mother nature and try to refund the nature what has been stolen from it. We and our many previous generations have stolen many trees from the mother nature and that has to refunded, returned to the mother nature. America is facing constant tornadoes and there is huge barren land not growing any try which are responsible for controling the speed flow of the wind. Soon india will face same kind of tornadoes as many jungles and trees have been cut down.
    It is first and foremost priority to refund what has been stolen from mother nature. The trees. Plant many trees and conserve them. This is the first option of spending black money inside india. Tiny irrigation projects is the second necessary investment to stop soil erosion during monsoon.
    Spend the money for :- Plantation of trees and conservation of those planted trees Funding tiny irrigation projects inside india (which will lead to water conservation and increase the ground water levels)
    Many government officers have perfected the art of diverting public money into their private pocket. The above two project be implemented in such a manner that every single rupee invested in the above project is utilised for the project only and not for anybody’s profit. If for nine years or more it is found that the above two schemes have been successfully implemented without single instance of corruption then only bring the money in railway lines and road transport like infrastructural development projects. When again for next nine years it is found that infrastructural development projects have been implemented without corruption then, bring the amount in water supply, water conservation, electricity projects. After yet another nine years invest the remaining amount in all branches of government functioning.
    Ask them (all black money holders) not to invest money in 1) Education or education sector, let the education sector grow independent of shadow of black money. Already many education institution have been secretly getting large amount of donations which are used in infrastructure and not in actual human resource development. Many pre-primary schools are charging more fees than any engineering or medical institutions, they don’t need any funding.
    2) Any industry, as most of the current industries are the source of generation of black money, they will again generate black money only. All the industries have been the third biggest black money generating tool in india ecomony. By evading production, sales and all sorts of taxes, by not intimating the actual production, income from industrial outputs have been converted into black money.
    3) Any infrastructural development as the same is resposibility of government and since the government had failed to perform many of its supervisory duty, inspection and control duties black money is gernerated. Many government contractor supply huge black money bribe to government official by over valuing the projects and add to their income. After agriculture, the government contractors are the biggest blakc money generating machines.
    4) Any Real estate, since the poor have been already snatched from their possiblity of getting a home and if such black money comes in, every poor will go out, poor class would literary became slave of rich class for their accomodation, residence demand.
    5) Agriculture – agriculture is the biggest sector from where the income of farmers have been regulary snatched away by the traders and stockists, it is the biggest sector where the black money is either generated or converted into white. All indian leaders holding crores of landed property evade tax by showing themselves and agriculturist or convert their black money as agriculture income on paper. Again bringing that black money as investment in that sector would disturb the economy only.
    All and all, nothing in india except the environment, is requiring these funds. Any fund coming inside will certainly disturb the entire economy. All those persons who personally own the black money and hold the same shall be asked to declare the same and use it abroad only.
    During all such major steps to be taken, it is very much necessary to stop future black money generation by restructuring the taxing procedures, levying and penalty formats.
    Our complicated tax structure brings challenge to evade the same.
    Simplify the taxing structures Keep the same as nine percent of pure profit
    Say in housing income from rented premises, after deducting every maintenace expenditure, what ever rent comes it would be nine percent of that rent.
    No tax to agriculture income for the farmer upto 18 acres. When any one person holds more than 18 acres of lands in his single name, and his profit exceeds Rs.1,80,000/- Then 9 % for any amount beyond Rs.1,80,000/-. While calculating his profit, every seed, manuer, water charges, energy charges, labour charges, transportation charges are to be deducted.
    For service tax :- Every individual employee have to directly pay the service tax to the government and the employee would not pay the same.
    For Production Tax :- The Manuafacturer would be required to pay 9 % of service tax on the MRP of the product.

     

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.