India! I dare you to be rich

N C Saxena’s scathing report on India’s bureaucracy

I chanced upon the following comment by Harsh Mander on NC Saxena's recent scathing report on India's bureaucracy, entitled: "Administrative Reforms for Better Governance". (The paper was launched on 26 November 2012 but doesn't seem to be available online.)

NC Saxena was Director of LBSNAA when I taught for a few months in 1994 before leaving for US for higher studies. Harsh was fellow faculty member. [See this extracted PDF containing all faculty members at LBS in 1994].

What is important here is that both NC Saxena and Harsh Mander have direct access to Sonia Gandhi, being members of the National Advisory Council. Yet it is self-evident that they have no influence in changing any policies.

I'm not sure whether NC Saxena or Harsh have read BFN, which critically analyses the causes of India's bureaucratic (and political) malaise, and offers straightforward proven solutions that will work – even in India. But they will require significant political will. I don't see any possibility of that with the Congress government.

In an important recent monograph by National Social Watch, scholar administrator NC Saxena … diagnoses the maladies of India’s higher civil services and suggests an imaginative range of possible prescriptions.
Saxena is scathing in his assessment of the Indian bureaucracy today. It is “a troubled institution” riddled with “a lack of professionalism, the creation of redundant posts, unsatisfactory structures of reward and punishment, and an inability to deliver services adequately”.
Postings are often “dictated by vested interest of mafia gangs, organised criminals, builders’ lobby, contractors”.
He observes that “over the years, whatever little virtues the civil services possessed — integrity, political neutrality, courage and high morale — are showing signs of decay”.
Newer values emphasise “political loyalty, flexibility”, and several senior officials “have become a link between politicians and the business class”.
Today many civil servants in the course of their career “lose much of their dynamism and innovativeness, and end up as mere pen-pushers and cynics, with “stagnation in their intellectual capabilities”, “decline in self-esteem”, “disillusionment, pliability and corruption”.
They have become agents of exploitation in a state structure which now (is)… authoritarian, brutal, directionless, and callous to the needs of the poor”.
The Indian State is “being treated as a private property of those who are at the top, and this culture of using executive power for private gains has become the norm since then. So the Housing Minister thinks that all government houses and shops are her private property, and she can allot them to any one she liked, often for a price. The Petroleum Minister thinks that he can distribute any number of petrol and kerosene depots at his discretion. An impression exists that the State of India is an open treasury that can be looted at will.”
Solutions … lie potentially with the people: a “free press, judicial activism, and civil society action has emerged as a big corrective factor on the arbitrary use of executive power”.

If you found this post useful, then consider subscribing to my blog by email:

Breaking Free of Nehru

Join the Freedom Team of India or become a Freedom Partner.

Print Friendly

Sanjeev Sabhlok

View more posts from this author
One thought on “N C Saxena’s scathing report on India’s bureaucracy
  1. Sandeep Datir

    If a person on NAC seems to be so helpless and incapable of having any influence to implement changes to improve the system , one wonders , who is actually running this country or is he just saying this for the sake of it.. But without genuine intentions… In either case it’s the country and its ppl will keep suffering from this.. They shud read BFN and show some guts to change the system..else ppl/country won’t forgive them..BTW just came across the fact that mr harsh had signed petition for kasab’s mercy plea amongst 202 others..fine..may be Myself and most of the ppl don’t have intellect or /kindness in our heart to understand his feelings for kasab but at least he and mr saxena should have guts to do the job they are supposed to do for the country and not for few elected politicians…


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.